Facts and Myths About Ideal Cut Diamonds

You might hear the words “Ideal Cut diamonds” when you’re beginning the ring shopping process, and wonder to yourself what is an Ideal Cut diamond? We would like to explain more about this term, the history behind it, and why Kwiat Tiara Diamonds offer a superior balance of proportions, resulting in diamonds that appear larger and more brilliant for a uniquely desirable engagement ring.

Facts and Myths About Ideal Cut Diamonds

The History of the Ideal Cut Diamond

So, what does an Ideal Cut diamond ring even mean? Historically speaking, the Ideal diamond cut was the invention of a man named Marcel Tolkowsky, who was a young engineering student from a prominent family of diamond cutters in Belgium. In the early 1900s, Tolkowsky published a doctoral thesis detailing how to achieve the most possible brilliance in a diamond. Through his studies on the physics of light, he created a formula for the specific proportions that, at the time, allowed a diamond to achieve its maximum fire and brilliance. This research was groundbreaking in Tolkowsky’s day and lead to the development of diamond cuts like the Old European cut. Tolkowsky’s Ideal Cut round diamond was the original forebearer of today’s Round Brilliant diamonds.

The Proportions of an Ideal Cut Diamond

In his initial research, Tolkowsky created strict parameters for Ideal Cut diamond proportions. Expressly, the crown angle must be 34.5 degrees, the pavilion angle must be 40.75 degrees, the total depth must be 59.3 percent and the table must be 53 percent. These distinct specifications enhanced brilliance, which is the amount of the white light reflected, and created more fire, which is the separation of white light into its spectral colors, than previous diamond-cutting techniques.

Through the ensuing decades, the diamond trade and several gem-grading laboratories adopted a broader range of guidelines that captured the spirit of Tolkowsky’s proportions for the diamond Ideal Cut but achieved better symmetry between those proportions for an overall more beautiful look. In detail, the crown angle may be between 34 and 36 degrees, the pavilion angle may be between 40 and 41.5 degrees, the total depth may range from 59 percent to 62.8 percent, and the table can range between 53 and 57 percent.


The Ideal Cut Diamond Today

While Tolkowsky’s research revolutionized the field of round diamond cutting in its day, the science behind the Ideal Cut round diamond has not entirely stood the test of time. Due to the work of the Gemological Institute of America® (GIA) and other leading diamond cutters, it’s widely accepted today that achieving maximum beauty in a diamond is not limited to one solitary set of proportions. For the GIA, Ideal Cut diamond proportions were merely a starting point.

An Ideal Cut Diamond vs Excellent Cut

More importantly, it’s the relationship between proportions that enhance brilliance, fire, and scintillation of a diamond. This relationship is at the core of GIA’s cut grading system. In fact, the GIA does not include “Ideal Cut” in its general usage. Rather, it employs the term “Excellent Cut” as its top diamond grade instead.

Try on Rings Together

The Problem with the Ideal Cut

Nowadays, the words “Ideal diamond cut” are little more than a marketing concept. Different brands, jewelers, and grading laboratories each have their own definition of what an Ideal Cut diamond ring is. Furthermore, developments over the last 100 years have shown that the Ideal Cut diamond parameters tend to favor fire over brightness and brilliance. It is also now understood that there are more visually attractive combinations of angles and proportions than this historic cut prescribes.

At Kwiat, we firmly stand by the scientific research of the GIA, the world’s leading authority on gemstones, and we feel strongly that the proportions of Ideal Cut diamonds are no longer the best way to cut a diamond. In particular, we believe that the table size, higher crown angle, and larger depth percentages of an Ideal Cut diamond make the stone seem smaller and lead to an unappealing fish-eye effect.

In contrast, Kwiat Tiara Diamonds are cut to appear larger and be more visually attractive, with a perfect balance of proportions that result in the brightest and most brilliant diamond possible.